His Friends are More than Fond of Robin – Carly Simon

Other than You’re So Vain and Nobody Does It Better (both of which I love, though I have a few reservations over some of the former’s more convoluted lyrics), I’d never given Carly Simon much thought until last year when Mel and I watched a Classic Albums documentary on No Secrets that a friend of mine recommended.

It’s rare that I watch one of those without my respect for the artist increasing (even Duran Duran went up in my estimation after watching the one on Rio), and Carly Simon was no exception. If I’d scoffed a bit about the idea of a Carly Simon episode of Classic Albums when none exists for Joni Mitchell or Neil Young, I wasn’t scoffing 55 minutes later. Maybe No Secrets is not After the Gold Rush or Blue, but it’s a really sturdy early 1970s pop-rock record, with three or four excellent songs aside from the obvious picks (The Right Thing to Do and You’re So Vain) that were released as singles.

His Friends are More than Fond of Robin is foremost among them. Piano-led and intimate, with Simon’s gentlest vocal performance, it’s a beautiful, quiet interlude on No Secrets, which otherwise tends to be a little more grandiose. Simon’s producer Richard Perry was fond of bigness and stuffed Simon’s songs with chugging cellos, big undamped tom-tom fills and multitudinous overdubs of lead and backing vocals. Wisely, Perry let His Friends are More than Fond of Robin breathe, and Simon responded with what must be her best released vocal performance.

Even more than the arrangement, though, what’s really noticeable about the song is how stylistically at odds this kind of writing is with that practised by her contemporaries. The pre-rock reference points for most singer-songwriters were folk, blues and country, and there were also a few who dabbled a little with jazz (or more truthfully, with some of the signifiers of jazz). But His Friends are More than Fond of Robin is not jazz – rather, it’s a sort of Broadway art song (the sort of thing that Stephen Sondheim might have written, as Barney Hoskyns observed in the Classic Albums doc). That’s a tradition that, among her contemporaries in 1970s rock, only Randy Newman ever worked in, although he’s not tended to write such vulnerably romantic material to perform himself.

All of which brings up an interesting question: why isn’t Carly Simon held in higher esteem than she is among the critics, fans, writers and bloggers who’ve shaped the singer-songwriter canon if she was capable of delivering pop hits as well as something with the depth of His Friends are More than Fond of Robin? Certainly there’s an element of sexism to it, and class is definitely an issue too (Simon is the daughter of Richard L Simon, co-founder of publishing house Simon & Schuster – a fact that critics such as Robert Christgau and Ellen Willis repeatedly held against her), but on the whole I think it’s that you can’t attach an obvious narrative to her, and canon formers love a narrative.

She didn’t have a prolonged streak of artistic brilliance of the kind that gave Neil and Joni their cred, or the history in music and compelling life story of Carole King, or the doomed-outsider cool of Tim Buckley or Judee Sill. Unlike, say, Jackson Browne, she didn’t even stop having hits – through the late 1970s and all through the 1980s, every time she seemed to be done commercially, she came back again with a successful single: Nobody Does it Better, Jesse, Why (written and produced by Chic, from the soundtrack to the movie Soup for One), Coming Around Again and, as late as 1989, Let the River Run (from the soundtrack to Working Girl). She didn’t have a gigantic, era-defining album hit like Paul Simon did with Graceland, but she never really went away. Not forgotten, just simply there, in a lot of people’s homes and hearts. Not obscure, not cool, not a genius, not a beautiful loser. Such artists are all too easily overlooked when canons are constructed.

While you’re here, can I trouble you to listen to this? It’s my new EP, available now (that’s NOW) from Bandcamp, iTunes, Spotify, Tidal, Google Play, Apple Music, and wherever you stream/download your music.

9 thoughts on “His Friends are More than Fond of Robin – Carly Simon

  1. David Allen Jones

    Perry worked with the late Paul Buckmaster on most of the songs on No Secrets, hence the “bigness” and “chugging cellos”, which were his stock in trade. Also, check out Boys in the Trees- I think THAT’S here most underrated album.

  2. farflownfalcon

    Continue to love your blogs Ross. A random wish-list of folk-rock artists for future posts: more John Martyn (obviously), Sandy Denny, Richard & Linda Thompson, Fotheringay, Neil Young, Joni Mitchell, and if we find ourselves in contemporary territory, Chris Wood, Glen Hansard or Nick Cave. I’d also love to read some posts about some reggae songs.

    Listening to your latest EP right now. And if I could trouble you to return the favour: https://farflownfalcon.bandcamp.com/album/the-apocalypse-lullaby-ep

    1. rossjpalmer Post author

      Thank you James! That’s very kind. I’ll see what I can re your wish-list. I have been considering taking on John Martyn’s One World as a whole, having done Small Hours a few years ago, so that may happen soon.

      Just listened to your EP and enjoyed it very much. Really nice work. 🙂

      1. farflownfalcon

        Thanks for listening. I’d love to read your thoughts on “One World” as a whole – it’s a great album and one that has always marked for me Martyn’s crossover from groundbreaking folk-jazz into territory which would hit the highs of Grace and Danger but then fall into a “drunken lounge singer with an overenthusiastic side man on the sax” ditch.

  3. Des Audain

    Ross…I LOVE “Separated by Water!” Just stumbled across this post. I’m a newbie producer/songwriter/keyboardist/singer. I started singing harmonies IMMEDIATELY to this. I hope you are doing something with this song. I hear it in a movie. I wish I knew more…I would love to collab with you. Oh, I have a small home studio (I don’t know what I’m doing yet) but I did a remake of “His Friends Are More Than Fond of Robin.” Would you/someone listen and give me their honest opinion? Thanks! Des Audain.

      1. rossjpalmer Post author

        Hi Des,
        Thank you so much for your very kind comments. 🙂 I’ve had a listen to your recording and I think it’s very well played and beautifully sung. If you’d like some more detailed feedback, I’d be happy to help. If you email me at rosspalmermusic@gmail.com , that might be best.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.